UK pledges reforms support

Zimbabwean

23 July 2010
HARARE – The British government has pledged to continue supporting reforms in Zimbabwe, saying the troubled southern African country’s future remains overshadowed by rule of law abuses and economic difficulties.

Speaking after meeting Zimbabwe’s Education Minister David Coltart in London last Tuesday, UK Foreign Office Minister Lord Howell praised the limited progress made so far by Harare’s coalition government in improving living standards for long-suffering Zimbabweans but said the country was far from improving its human rights and economic track record.

“He assured Minister Coltart of the UK’s continuing assistance to help bolster reform and achieve their aims of a stable, democratic and prosperous Zimbabwe,” the British Foreign Office said in a statement.

Coltart was in London last week at the invitation of the Council for Education in the Commonwealth and the Link  Community Development Trust which organised a conference on challenges faced by Zimbabwe’s education sector.

The UK and other Western powers have withheld budgetary support for Zimbabwe’s 17-month-old coalition government until there is evidence of “concrete progress” in implementing political reforms.

The Western nations have demanded full implementation of a power-sharing agreement between President Robert Mugabe and Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai as a condition for resumption of budgetary support for Zimbabwe.

Implementation of the agreement has been marred by bickering between Mugabe’s ZANU PF party and the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) led by Tsvangirai over appointment of key regime officials and the pace of political reforms.

Relations between Britain and Zimbabwe soured after London and its Western allies imposed visa and financial sanctions on Mugabe and his top lieutenants as punishment for violating human rights, stealing elections and failure to uphold the rule of law.

Mugabe denies the charges and instead accuses Britain of reneging on promises to fund land reform in Zimbabwe and charges that London and its Western allies have funded his opponents in a bid to oust him from power as punishment for seizing white land for redistribution to blacks.

Posted in Press reports | Leave a comment

Outside looking in – a letter from the diaspora

Zimbabwean

Written by Pauline Henson

23 July 2010

Dear Friends,


I suppose it’s not really surprising that Zimbabwe doesn’t feature very highly on the world’s news agenda at the moment. The problem – or one of them – is that nothing seems to be happening. The conclusion most non-Zimbabweans draw from that, if they think about it at all, is that things must now be OK in Zimbabwe. On the basis that ‘No news is good news’ they assume that the GNU must be working and all is now quiet in the formerly troubled country. It is no longer one of the world’s trouble spots. Zimbabwe, it seems has solved its problems by the formation of a coalition government with former enemies working amicably together. That’s how it looks from the outside to the uninformed and even to Zimbabweans in exile in the diaspora the news is sometimes very confusing. Take this week for an example. The KP’s decision to allow Zimbabwe to sell her diamonds on the open market was welcomed by both sides of the political divide regardless of any previous condemnation of human rights abuses and the militarization of the diamond fields. And in Harare there was the big news was that Mugabe’s politburo and the two MDC leaders and their delegations had met “to discuss ways to end the violence.” On the face of it that seems a very positive development and that’s exactly where the confusion comes in. If, as both sides are repeatedly claiming, everything is going well in Zimbabwe and the MDC and Zanu PF are getting on fine, why is there still violence on the ground and particularly in the rural areas? Why is the Constitutional Outreach Programme beset with problems of violence and attempts to silence dissenting voices by Zanu PF thugs? Why are MDC officials constantly being harassed and arrested by the partisan police force?
Has the Unity Government lived up to expectations? Are things improving or are they not? Watching David Coltart’s interview shown on the World Service’s Hard Talk I was struck by his equivocal answer to that blunt question. Things are much better than they were, he said, the problem was that people’s expectations were too high! There is food in the shops now he claimed but made little mention of the fact that it was often unaffordable to the poor, though the economy has improved he maintained and the media has been partially freed up. This in the same week that the ZTV/BC resumed its playing of Zanu PF jingles denigrating the GNU and their MDC ‘partners’.  Schools and hospitals are functioning again, Coltart claimed. It all sounded quite rosy but then Coltart would say that wouldn’t he? He and other MDC and Zanu PF ministers are in the UK on a begging trip, appealing for funds. They have to put a positive spin on the situation to attract the investment they so desperately need. What Coltart couldn’t quite bring himself to say was that no one is going to invest in a country where the rule of law is meaningless, where property rights are ignored and the police continue to turn a blind eye to Zanu PF’s blatant disregard of human and democratic rights. Coltart admitted that the situation on the farms has deteriorated even further in recent months but he was careful not to say what every Zimbabwean knows: that Robert Mugabe’s so-called Land Reform has been nothing short of disaster for the country leading to widespread hunger and unemployment.
As for the question of what should happen to Robert Mugabe and his cronies in the police and the army, it was Tendayi Biti, the Finance Minister, back in Harare who put forward the argument that the only way to get him to give up power was to offer him and his cronies immunity from prosecution in exchange for the promise that they would not be arrested or lose their stolen farms if they just quietly retire from the scene. This extraordinary suggestion seems to have provoked very little comment back in Zimbabwe but speaking personally, I cannot accept that any Minister from any party has the right to set aside an individual’s rights in such a way. How can a Government Minister decide that property that was legally owned and paid for by virtue of Title Deeds can now belong in perpetuity to the thief who stole it? That is nothing more than a criminals’ charter and every land grabber in the country must be rubbing his hands in glee at the thought that his ill-gotten gains – be they farms, crops, tractors, irrigation pipes or household goods stolen during the land invasions – cannot now be taken from him.  There seems little difference to me between Zanu PF  Minister Chinamasa’s statement this week that Zimbabwe would ignore the rulings of the SADC Tribunal in favour of the Zimbabwean farmers and an MDC Minister’s offer of immunity in exchange for retaining stolen property. In neither case is this a true reflection of what is meant by adherence to the rule of law. While an international Advocacy Group calls on the UN Security Council to prosecute Robert Mugabe and warns of the imminent threat of 2008-style violence in the forthcoming elections, the MDC continues its support for the status quo on the grounds that the GNU is the only way forward for the country to avoid the terrible violence of the past.  MDC people such as David Coltart are no doubt well-meaning, sincere and utterly committed to Zimbabwe but in going along with Zanu PF and Robert Mugabe, knowing their violent history, the MDC is guilty of extreme naivety that may well bring down even worse violence on the heads of innocent Zimbabweans in the months ahead.
Yours in the (continuing) struggle PH.aka Pauline Henson author of Case Closed published by Mambo Press, Going Home and Countdown, political detective stories set in Zimbabwe and available from Lulu.com

Posted in Blog, Press reports | 1 Comment

BBC Hard Talk on Zimbabwe 3 of 3

Interview to David Coltart, Zimbabwean cabinet minister

Posted in Multimedia | Leave a comment

BBC Hard Talk on Zimbabwe 2 of 3

Interview to David Coltart, Zimbabwean cabinet minister

Posted in Multimedia | Leave a comment

BBC interview with Henry Olonga and David Coltart

BBC 5 Live Sport

22 July 2010

You can listen back to the BBC Radio 5 live interview in which Henry Olonga questions David Coltart at http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b00t4nbz/5_live_Sport_22_07_2010/. Listen from about 6 minutes in.

BBC iPlayer – 5 live Sport: 22/07/2010

www.bbc.co.uk

Listen to 5 live Sport

Posted in Blog | Leave a comment

MDC Ministers in London to woo donors and investors

SW Radio Africa

By Lance Guma

22 July 2010


Three cabinet ministers from the two MDC formations, plus Deputy Prime Minister Arthur Mutambara, were in London on Thursday addressing two separate meetings that sought to woo investors and donors to help with Zimbabwe’s economic recovery. The ministers were accompanied by their permanent secretaries and other senior civil servants from their ministries.

Education, Sport, Arts and Culture Minister, Senator David Coltart, addressed a conference to drum up support for the education sector. The conference was put together by the Commonwealth Consortium for Education and the Link Community Development. Present at the meeting were several donor agencies and NGO’s working in the field of education and Coltart pitched his future plans for rehabilitating the education sector in Zimbabwe.

Across town in Westminster, Deputy Prime Minister Mutambara, cabinet ministers Joel Gabbuza (Public Works) and Sam Sipepa Nkomo (Water Resources) attended an investment conference organized by the Zimbabwe Institute of Engineers. Among those invited to speak was Econet’s CEO Douglas Mboweni, Zimbabwe’s Ambassador to the UK Gabriel Machinga and former Industry and Trade Minister Nkosana Moyo, now Vice President and Chief Operating Officer of the African Development Bank.

The Zimbabwe Institute of Engineers said the conference was “intended to bring together the government of Zimbabwe, diplomats, engineers, consultants, investors, financiers, fund managers and multi-national companies, to examine infrastructure investment opportunities in the four key areas of water, sanitation, transportation, energy and ICTs.”

Newsreel spoke to Senator Coltart on the sidelines of the education conference and asked him how the coalition hoped to resolve the challenges facing the country if their ZANU PF partners continued pulling in a different direction and continued with their endless human rights violations. Coltart said there were elements in ZANU PF that were determined to see the coalition collapse.

“It’s very difficult given there are elements within ZANU PF who don’t like this agreement, in fact who hate it and who want to break it and they, I believe are the ones behind these egregious acts. They are the ones directing these prosecutions and directing ongoing farm invasions. Their purpose is clear. To keep the international community disengaged, to try to force the combined MDC formations to walk away from this agreement.’

Coltart said although they could not dismiss or ignore these actions they had to find a way to work around them and ‘have in mind that the ultimate goal is this transition.’ He said they were hoping a new constitution, new electoral laws and the freeing up of the media would lead to a free and fair election or at the very least an election better than the one held last time.

A participant in the meeting questioned the minister on what impact the sale of diamonds, recently approved by the Kimberly Process, would have on the attempts to revamp the education sector. Coltart found it difficult to answer this and admitted he was going to be vague, saying they were trying to put measures in place to ensure money from the diamonds would find its way into state coffers and not just into the hands of the ruling elite.

There has been criticism that while Mugabe’s regime focus on retaining power they are using the MDC face of the government to go around the world asking for money to rebuild the country. On Thursday it was there for all to see, with 3 cabinet ministers from the MDC formations doing the PR for the government in a western country, while ZANU PF appointed permanent secretaries and other probable CIO minders looked on.

Posted in Press reports | Leave a comment

15000 Teachers back in class

Zimbabwean

By Fungi Kwaramba

22 July 2010

HARARE – More than 15 000 teachers have rejoined the profession since the unity government took office last year and improved salaries for civil servants including teachers, Education Minister David Coltart said last week. 

However Coltart said while remuneration for teachers was sufficient to lure them back to classrooms it remained well below preferable levels, adding that he was pushing the government to improve salaries for the country’s educators.
“Despite the low salaries that teachers are getting over 15 000 have returned since last year blanket amnesty for all teachers to return,” Coltart said last week.
“Teachers are being paid sufficiently to get back into the system, but I reiterate that I understand that teachers salaries are inadequate and I am continuously arguing in cabinet for equality in the civil service. There are many people in the civil service who are being paid far more than teachers,” he added.
Education experts say Zimbabwe requires about 150 000 trained teachers for effective teaching but has plus or minus 100 000 teachers in schools because of a severe brain drain that saw thousands of the country’s best qualified educators either leaving the country for better paying jobs abroad or leaving teaching to join other more rewarding sectors of the economy.
Several hundreds more teachers are also said to have left schools especially in rural areas after unprecedented post-electoral violence that swept across the country following the defeat of President Robert Mugabe and his ruling Zanu (PF) party in elections in March 2008.
Teachers were targeted for attack by Zanu (PF) militia and war veterans who accused them of campaigning for the then opposition MDC party of Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai.
The exodus of teachers coupled with the government’s inability over the past 10 years of recession to maintain schools or provide learning materials such as chalks, textbooks and exercise books has left Zimbabwe’s once revered education sector a mere shadow of its former self.
Coltart, who has battled to revive the public education sector despite scarce resources, said his ministry will push hard to restore dignity to the teaching profession that many young Zimbabweans now shun because of its record of poor pay and working conditions.
He said: “My first priority is to ensure that teachers are paid sufficiently so as to restore their integrity. The good side is that we have an incredibly dedicated teaching staff which is the essential ingredient in improving the education sector.”
Teachers in Zimbabwe’s public schools earn an average US$236 monthly wage as the power-sharing government struggles to revive an economy battered by years of hyperinflation, lure back investors and pay its workers.

Posted in Press reports | Leave a comment

BBC Hard Talk on Zimbabwe

Interview to David Coltart, Zimbabwean cabinet minister.

Posted in Multimedia | Leave a comment

MDC minister David Coltart says an “evolutionary process” will gradually bring democracy to Zimbabwe

BBC Radio 4

22 July 2010

Today

MDC minister David Coltart says an “evolutionary process” will gradually bring democracy to Zimbabwe via web

r4today

BBC Radio 4 Today

Posted in Blog | Leave a comment

Sanctions benefit Zanu PF: Coltart

New Zimbabwe.com

By Mduduzi Mathuthu

21 July 2010

EDUCATION Minister David Coltart says Western sanctions on Zimbabwe are “past their sell-by-date” and are now being used by President Robert Mugabe’s Zanu PF party to hinder the full implementation of a 2008 power sharing agreement.

Coltart, who describes his relationship with Mugabe over the last 30 years as “chequered”, also insists in a BBC interview that the pact signed following disputed and violence-marred elections was the only non-violent option available to the President’s rivals.

Asked by the BBC’s Hardtalk host Stephen Sackur if he thought sanctions should be lifted, Coltart replied: “They were largely symbolic, there were never any economic sanctions against Zimbabwe, they were targeted against individual members. Those who imposed these sanctions gave so much notice for example on the financial sanctions that most Zanu PF hierarchy actually got their money out, so they never really had any impact in the first place.

“Ironically, my view now is that sanctions are being used most effectively by Zanu PF. They use sanctions as the reason why they should not implement other clauses in the [power sharing] agreement. So to that extent, I believe sanctions are past their sell-by-date.”

Mugabe’s party has refused to move on key government appointments until sanctions are lifted — referencing a clause in the Global Political Agreement which implores the power sharing partners to campaign for their removal.

Coltart said the European Union and the United States had shown “understandable scepticism” about a power sharing arrangement which retains President Mugabe, but rails against what he sees as a “purist approach” to Zimbabwe – an approach not exercised anywhere else where countries are coming out of conflict situations.

“They are very sceptical, and I understand why they are sceptical,” Coltart said in the interview which aired on Tuesday and Wednesday. “They view Robert Mugabe as a wily politician. I think that they are wrong. I think they are trying to be purist in their approach. They didn’t apply that standard to the Good Friday Agreement [in Northern Ireland] …

“If people in Ireland said they weren’t going to enter into an agreement because of what the IRA had done in the past, there would never have been a Good Friday Agreement and Northern Ireland would be stuck in the mire still.

“If you go back to the Second World War, if you adopted a purist approach, [Winston] Churchill would have never spoken to [Joseph] Stalin. We came to the same point in our history, and you’ve got to put the past aside in many respects to move ahead.

“We had a much bigger danger facing our nation, namely total collapse, degeneration … and to that extent, I don’t believe that the international community has given this arrangement a chance.”

Coltart, a long-time critic of Mugabe – first as a human rights lawyer and later as an MP – defended the pact signed between Mugabe’s Zanu PF party and the two rival MDC factions led by Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai and Deputy Prime Minister Arthur Mutambara.

“It’s been in many respects a tense relationship. It’s very hard to trust anyone who has been responsible for gross human rights violations,” Coltart, a senior member of Mutambara’s MDC, said of his own personal relationship with the President. “But what applies nationally, applies personally. We had no other viable non-violent option other than to go into this arrangement, and to that extent we have to put history aside and work in the interests of the nation — and that includes working with Robert Mugabe.”

Posted in Press reports | Leave a comment