Financial Gazette

Thursday,22 September 2011 

By Clemence Manyukwe, Political Editor

JUSTICE and Legal Affairs Minister, Patrick Chinamasa, is allegedly critical of the Attorney General (AG)’s Office which he considers as incompetent.

Chinamasa, who was once the country’s AG before he was appointed into cabinet, also believes that it is wrong for the AG, Johannes Tomana, to align himself with ZANU-PF, according to the latest leaked United States cables.

The cable details a meeting between a US official and former deputy justice minister, Jessie Majome, of the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC-T).

Majome allegedly described Chinamasa as “frank and open” as well as a proponent of professionalism.

A commentary by the US officials added that during his time as AG, Chinamasa was regarded as a technically competent bureaucrat.

“She (Majome) also told us that Chinamasa held Tomana in low regard because of the clumsy manner and legal incompetence his office often demonstrated,” reads part of the cables.

“Similarly, Attorney General Tomana has openly told her that she is subordinate to him within the ministry because he sits in Cabinet and she does not. Tomana, according to Majome, is arrogant, has a Mercedes and a driver, travels in a two car convoy, and moves on foot with a four-person security detail.”

Majome is alleged to have indicated that at meetings, ministry officials circumvent her by, for example, failing to copy her correspondence within the ministry or notify her of any briefings.

The MDC-T official is said to have cited a press conference where the ministry’s permanent secretary, David Mangota and prisons commissioner, Paradzai Zimondi, announced a general amnesty to cover a thousand prisoners, a development she only read in the newspapers.

Majome is alleged to have added that the prisons system has become militarised, with retiring soldiers assuming jobs intended to be filled by the civilian prison service.

“This has also occurred in the AG’s office where soldiers have replaced technicians and legal aides,” Majome is alleged to have said.

In its commentary, the US embassy said: “Majome’s experience highlights the lack of cooperation occurring at the ministerial level in what purports to be an inclusive government.

“Even in instances where the ministry is led by an MDC minister, such as David Coltart’s Ministry of Education, there is often a struggle between the minister and his Mugabe-appointed permanent secretary.”

The embassy added that the cases present a tremendous hurdle in implementing policy changes that are opposed by ZANU-PF loyalists.

The balance of power within ministries was said to be in favour of ZANU-PF.

Zimbabwean

By Brenna Matendere Munyati

21 September 2011

Technical subjects should be prioritised above subjects such as history because they are more likely to equip students to contribute to the economy, said Deputy Higher Education Minister Senator Lutho Addington Tapela.

Speaking at the graduation of over 600 students from Gweru Polytechnic college over the weekend, Sen Tapela said pupils in the country’s secondary schools should be equipped with skills to earn a living after their studies.

“If you teach children bricklaying, in a short while they can earn a living and contribute to the economy. But with history what do you do?” he asked.

His words come at a time when the Zanu (PF) side of the coalition government has been pushing for history to be made compulsory in schools. The party has also proposed to have the dreaded war veterans teach the subject in secondary schools.

Analysts have labelled the call brainwashing. Education Minister Senator David Coltart condemned the development in parliament saying it violated Government policy.

Starting from next year, Sen Tapela announced that Gweru Polytechnic College would be pouring teachers of technical subjects into secondary schools across the country.

“We want to see technical subjects being made more available to students. It’s good for their survival after school. It reduces poverty and pulls down the unemployment rates,” he said.

Newsday

Editorial Comment 

19 September 2011

Reports that excommunicated Anglican church leader Nolbert Kunonga last week evicted headmasters, teachers and priests for allegedly aligning themselves with the diocese of his arch-rival Chad Gandiya made sad reading.

Especially so after the Zanu PF-aligned church leader left thousands of schoolchildren at Daramombe in Chivhu among others without their shepherds.

The spate of evictions in Chivhu, Murehwa and other areas has unfortunately thrown the name of the Church of England into disrepute.

This however has revealed Kunonga’s insatiable appetite for both power and wealth. Since he lost control of the Anglican Church first to Sebastian Bakare and later to Gandiya, Kunonga, who has ingratiated himself with Zanu PF, has committed acts of atrocities on innocent people as if he was above the law.

Kunonga is the excommunicated Bishop of the Province of the Central Africa Harare Diocese, who now runs a rival church, the Anglican Church Province of Zimbabwe.

Whether he is fighting a good cause or not, it is not for anyone to say, but the public will always ask themselves why Kunonga’s actions have left thousands of disadvantaged children out in the open at the mercy of the weather. In many cases innocent children have found themselves in the crossfire.

Over 100 orphans at Shearly Cripps Children’s Home in Murehwa were recently left stranded when caregivers, including nuns, were chucked out.

A few days later Kunonga was at it again evicting the priest and headmasters of Daramombe primary and secondary schools in Chivhu, leaving the children without a shepherd.

The eviction of headmasters was ill-advised and ill-timed given that some of the children will soon be sitting for their final examinations.

One could not agree more with Minister of Education, Sport, Arts and Culture David Coltart who on Friday unequivocally condemned the ejection of headmasters saying it was not in the interest of the schoolchildren. The school authorities could not just be changed like that at this time.

Coltart is right that changing headmasters is detrimental to the students, especially when this happens in the third term with public examinations about to start in the coming weeks.

Kunonga’s actions are despite last Thursday’s High Court decision to defer ruling on the wrangle in which Gandiya’s diocese is seeking a stay of ejectment from church properties.

The ruling is set for September 23.

In that vein, one would question why Kunonga is subverting the law.

He should be made aware that the time of reckoning is just around the corner for anyone flouting the law of the land regardless of how well-connected he might be.

• Congrats to Kirsty Coventry for her 4 gold medal haul at the All Africa Games which has helped take Zimbabwe to 5th on the the medal table #
• I am pleased that my friend John Makumbe has finally announced what we knew all along – that he was partisan which after all is his right #
• TheStar Malawians protest a nation in decline: http://t.co/FaNJHmp via @TorontoStar #
• Nice evening with the entire Pakistan cricket team – they were very complimentary about Zimbabwe Cricketers and look forward to another tour #
• Cracking 30 off 13 from Coventry – hopefully this will make our selectors remember his worth – he's an automatic pick for 50 overs as well #
• Nice to see the "Zimbabwean Beast" scoring for South Africa in Rugby World Cup – seems Australia needed the other Zimbabwean David Pocock #

Newsday 

17 September 2011

By Feluna Nleya

As Nolbert Kunonga’s onslaught in the Anglican Church continues, schoolchildren at Daramombe Mission in Chivhu were on Friday left shepherdless after the Zanu PF-aligned bishop reportedly evicted headmasters, teachers and priests for allegedly aligning themselves with the diocese of his rival, Chad Gandiya.

The evictions come hard on the heels of similar action at a children’s home in Murehwa on Tuesday, where over 100 orphans were reportedly left in a similar predicament after caregivers, who included nuns, were chucked out.

A priest at Daramombe on Friday confirmed the evictions.

“The messenger of court came on Monday and I was evicted then. On Tuesday they came back again and evicted the headmasters of both the primary and secondary schools, and also some teachers including the boarding master.”

“They initially came in April and told us that the school was now under the Diocese of Harare and we should now be in his (Kunonga’s) congregation, but that is not what we wanted hence we were evicted,” the priest said.

The evictions come after the Kunonga faction wrote a circular to Anglican institutions, warning that those who did not play ball and worship under his diocese faced expulsions.

“This circular serves to notify you those teachers and non-teaching staff are to be removed or transferred elsewhere, since they are in disagreement with the ethos of the responsible authority, Diocese of Harare,” the letter read.

“Any head who does not take action concerning the issue will in turn be answerable to the Archbishop of the Diocese of Harare Anglican Church in Zimbabwe,” reads part of the letter.

On Tuesday, Kunonga caused a national stir when he unleashed a messenger of court at Shearly Cripps Children’s Home in Murehwa to evict caregivers looking after orphans.

The crisis has seen the Minister of Education, Sport, Arts and Culture, David Coltart, clash with his deputy, Lazarus Dokora.

Said Coltart on Friday: “I unequivocally condemn this act . . . It is not in the interest of the schoolchildren that the authorities could just be changed like that at this time. This is detrimental to the students especially when this has to happen in the third term with public examinations about to start in the few coming weeks. I am, however, waiting for a report from the provincial office through the permanent secretary.”

The minister’s position is in sharp contrast to Dokora’s statements early this week, when he opted to fold arms.

“I understand there is a Supreme Court ruling and in the first instance headmasters are recommended by the church.

“They come from the responsible authorities and they look for their own teachers. We can’t intervene in issues of belief,” Dokora told NewsDay.

However, Kunonga’s actions come despite Thursday’s High Court decision to defer ruling on the wrangle in which Bishop Gandiya’s diocese is seeking stay of ejectment from church properties.

The ruling is set for September 23.

Senator David Coltart

Westwood, Harare, 15^th September 2011 

Address by Education Minister David Coltart at the

School for All: 30^th Anniversary of Leonard Cheshire Zimbabwe Trust Launch of an Inclusive Education manual entitled “Breaking Down Barriers to Inclusive Education in Zimbabwe”

Ladies and Gentlemen and Children

The Inclusive Education Teacher’s Handbook being officially launched here today is an important event. We rather like the word ‘inclusive’ – it is the inclusive government which has brought Zimbabwe back from the brink of destruction, so it’s a good concept which must be applied to education. It sets out to facilitate the management of children with and without disabilities in the same classroom environment. I am delighted to hear of the progress made in schools since Vice President Mujuru and I launched the Inclusive Policy last year.

Zimbabwe is well known for its commitment to providing education for all its children. It has been my ministry’s desire for many years to see children with disabilities included in ordinary schools. The launch of the Inclusive Education Teacher’s Handbook today is a milestone development that is a culmination of several dedicated players, with Leonard Cheshire Zimbabwe Trust taking the leading role in coordinating this development process and assisted by officers from my Ministry and those from the Zimbabwe Open University. I wish to commend all those who took an active part in making the dream become true. I am also aware of the work done by the Directorate in the schools psychological services and Special Needs Education Department, some District Education Officers, Headmasters and teachers.  I am also aware of the wonderful contribution made by organisations such as the Dorothy Duncan Centre and King George VI. I also acknowledge support of UNICEF and partners in the Education Transition Fund, which has resulted in the production of Braille books which are now in all schools countrywide.

However, while we do have children with disabilities in some of your schools and have a number of schools with special classes for children with learning disabilities, a number of factors have militated against the full realisation of our ideals.

A major limitation has been inadequate resources. The difficult years of hyperinflation have seen many previously well resourced schools struggling to provide basic educational materials and keep their furniture and equipment in good repair. In addition, our centre in Mount Pleasant is in a very poor state. Equipment is not working. They recently had a meeting with the CEO of a local bank and are hoping that they will rehabilitate it.

Government’s thrust to provide education for everyone required huge resources and Government has had to rely on parents and communities to play a major role in providing many of the resources that their schools and children need.

Resource constraints affected too special units within schools for children with learning disabilities. Some of these units had very little in the way of special teaching aids. In some case parents formed support groups for these classes and purchased some of the equipment they needed.

Schools specifically for children with disabilities, such as those run by the Jairos Jiri Association, King George VI, Zimcare and St Giles, also suffered severe resource restraints in recent years.

We welcome partnerships with non-governmental organisations such as Leonard Cheshire in trying to ensure that all our children are able to enjoy a high quality of education.

When it comes to integrating children with disabilities into schools with a predominantly non-disabled enrolment, the difficulties in achieving this go beyond resources.

Whilst the lack of ramps and toilets designed for pupils with disabilities may be a limiting factor , I am pleased to see that Leonard Cheshire has already made remarkable adaptations in 19 schools since the inception of this programme.

However, another major limitation is the attitude of families, communities, teachers, parents and other children towards children with disabilities. I am pleased that this is an area that the Leonard Cheshire project is tackling too through their disability community awareness and sensation programme.

While we are proud of the fact that most of the schools in which this project began already have children with disabilities enrolled as a result of this programme, it is obviously a matter of concern that there are many more children with disabilities who have not enrolled in school.

This project is already helping the targeted government schools to overcome the challenges they face in catering for disabled as well as able-bodied children. It should also facilitate the eventual enrolment in these schools of other disabled children who are not currently attending school.

My Ministry shares the Leonard Cheshire Zimbabwe Trust’s vision of children with disabilities and able-bodied students eventually learning together in schools throughout the country.

What is most encouraging about this project is its practical approach and the dynamism that has already been displayed in getting this project off the ground.

I very much hope it will be successful. However, we must not underestimate the difficulties.

A major difficulty in Government schools is sure to be the pupil to teacher ratio which is too high in many of our schools, with a single teacher often having to teach 50 children. With that number of children in a class, it becomes difficult for a teacher to give children the individual attention they require. Where a child need extra help the problem is worse still. We therefore urge parents to take an active part in helping alleviate some of the challenges teachers face by participating as classroom assistants.

In schools that have a special unit for children with learning disabilities, some of whom have a degree of physical disability as well, other teachers sometimes resent the lower pupil to teacher ratio that is necessary in these classes.

The trend in many countries is towards integrating children with disabilities in ordinary schools along with the non-disabled. However, often this is at a policy level and there is less keenness for it at the school level.

Organisations such as Leonard Cheshire are needed not only to lobby for the inclusion of disabled children in ordinary schools and the provision of facilities to accommodate them but to educate parents and teachers.

The Government believes that every child should have the right to go to school and to have an education. It would be my wish that my Ministry did more to promote the integration of children with disabilities in ordinary schools. However, you are all aware of the severe financial constraints my Ministry is faced with. In terms of this year’s budget I have less than US$2 per child per month to educate them, an impossible task without partners.

We welcome this initiative, therefore, which has been clearly well thought out, providing as it does for the targeting of specific schools, training of teachers in inclusive teaching methods, development of manuals to assist teachers, implementing adaptations such as toilets and ramps, educating parents and community members on disability issues and facilitating the provision of mobility aids for children requiring them. Most importantly we need to applaud Leonard Cheshire for facilitating the development of a Teacher’s Handbook on Inclusive Education for use by all schools in Zimbabwe, a development that is quite historic indeed.

This is a critical handbook which I believe will benefit considerably not only those schools that have been targeted but also other schools and communities outside the pilot zone.

This is, of course, a pilot project. The hope is that it will prove so successful that the concept of inclusive education will be extended to all our schools.

I would certainly like to see training in inclusive education being taught at all our teacher training colleges. Every teacher should be able to teach in an inclusive education environment. This also encourages non-government schools to teach inclusively. An example of a school I have had a close interest in is Petra, which works very closely with King George VI in Bulawayo, especially at Upper Sixth level. As I speak I two graduates with severe disabilities have now been enrolled in US universities having obtained scholarships – for them the sky is the limit, and should be for all.

I should like to congratulate Leonard Cheshire Disability and the Leonard Cheshire Zimbabwe Trust for initiating this project. I can assure them that they will continue to have the full cooperation and support of my Ministry.

I would like to thank the Anglo American Group Foundation for sponsoring this project and would encourage other corporate bodies to help organisations like Leonard Cheshire to make a difference to our society.

This is a worthwhile project. I am sure that, working together, my Ministry and Leonard Cheshire will be able to make this project a success and an important step towards more widespread inclusive education.

It is now my honour to finally launch the Inclusive Education Teacher’s Handbook.

Thank you.

Zimbabwean

By Ngoni Chanakira

15 September 2011

Zimbabwe’s Minister of Education, Sport and Culture, Senator David Coltart, will tonight join several diplomats to celebrate Alliance Francaise’s 60th Anniversary.

Coltart, a Senator from the Professor Welshman Ncube-led MDC political party, will be Guest of Honour at the event.

A spokesman for Alliance Francaise said: “Yes I can confirm that Education Minister, Mr David Coltart, will be Guest of Honour at the cocktail function here tonight.

The event will feature Ambassadors, corporate executives, senior journalists, and cultural figures based in Harare.

“This is among the many top events celebrating our 60 years operating in Zimbabwe and our presence to re-assert the strength of friendship between France and Zimbabwe after 60 years of collaboration,” the spokesman said.

Charles Houdart, the AF boss, will host the event.

The spokesman said in an interview that since 1951, AF had been hosting and organising pluri-disciplinary cultural events in Zimbabwe.

“The events include concerts, exhibitions, cinema showings, theatre performances, as well as the annual Francophone Week, usually held in March,” he said.

“We also take part in many local and cultural projects such as the Harare International Festival of the Arts (HIFA) and the Zimbabwe International Film Festival (ZIFF).

“During the 60 years, the Alliance Francaise of Harare has pursued three main missions according to its values, and we should not be ashamed to say that we have done well”.

The spokesman said Alliance Francaise offers French lessons, increased the awareness of French and Francophone culture, and provided a platform for enhancing the Zimbabwe/France cultural network.

He said during the 60th Anniversary celebrations the AF would host the cocktail party tonight for “invited VIPs only”.

On Friday it will host an international “DJ – Funkalicious”, while top group “Gargar” is expected to entertain guests later during the night.

Gargar is an all female group from Kenya.

The spokesman said the Friday night event would be hosted by the resident Master of Ceremonies (MC), “Comrade Fatso”.

“We are expecting more than 300 people to enjoy the music performed by our artists until dawn and celebrate as it has to be the 60th Anniversary of the Alliance de Harare with us,” the spokesman said in an interview.

The events are being sponsored by Harare’s Courtney Hotel (accommodation for artists), Spar (Zimbabwe) (Private) Limited (cocktail party including food and drinks), and I-Way Africa (Private) Limited, a leading regional internet service provider (Information Communication Technology (ICT) activities).

The Zimbabwe Mail

By Patience Nyangove

12 September 2011

DEFENCE minister Emmerson Mnangagwa allegedly pleaded with Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai five years ago to include him in a future MDC government, a leaked United States embassy cable has revealed.

According to the secret cable dated June 2006, made public by the whistleblower website WikiLeaks last week, MDC-T secretary general Tendai Biti allegedly told a US embassy official Eric Schultz that Tsvangirai had been secretly discussing a power-sharing deal with Zanu PF officials.

Biti allegedly identified the Zanu PF officials as Mnangagwa and the late former army commander Solomon Mujuru. Mnangagwa could not be reached for comment yesterday.He said while Mngangwa was willing to be Tsvangirai’s subordinate in the proposed government, Mujuru wanted the then popular opposition leader to be a junior partner.

“According to Biti, Mnangagwa was willing to subordinate himself to Tsvangirai in exchange for cabinet slots and protection guarantees for affiliated businesses,” reads part of the cable.

“Biti said Mujuru was only offering to take Tsvangirai in as a junior partner, which he said reflected the Mujuru faction’s continued primacy.” The cable also alleges that MDC leader Welshman Ncube had offered Biti the post of president in his faction before they brought in Arthur Mutambara.

“He said Ncube had offered him the presidency of the pro-senate faction, but that he had no regrets about remaining with Tsvangirai in spite of his faults,” Schultz wrote in the cable.

Biti is also quoted accusing Education, Sport and Culture minister David Coltart of being obsessed with race. Coltart had allegedly written an email to an official at the US embassy accusing the MDC-T faction of being behind the intra-party violence that led to the split of the MDC in 2005.

Biti, who could not be reached for comment, compared Coltart, who could also not be reached for comment, to MDC-T treasurer Roy Bennett, who speaks Shona fluently. “Bennett was culturally Zimbabwean; Coltart, who spoke not a word of the local language, would always be an outsider,” Schultz wrote in the cable.

_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Webmaster’s Note:

The original text from the US Cable sent in June 2006 is as follows:

“(C) Biti emphasized the centrality of Morgan Tsvangirai 

to the opposition’s political fortunes.  Though not without 

faults, Tsvangirai commanded more respect and enthusiasm from 

the masses than any other figure in either faction of either 

party.  The tens of thousands he drew in rallies across the 

country — and the overtures from ZANU-PFQ,s factions — were 

testament to that.  TsvangiraiQ,s commitment to non-violent 

but open challenges to the regime reflected the desires of 

the country. 

¶6.  (C) Biti was excoriating in his assessment of pro-senate 

faction-aligned MP David Coltart’s recent missive (e-mailed 

to AF/S) attacking the Tsvangirai faction for violence.  He 

asserted that the intra-party violence Coltart raised was 

exaggerated and not encouraged or condoned by the party 

leadership.  He noted that those most reviled within the 

anti-senate faction — Welshman Ncube and Gift Chimanakire, 

for example — lived, worked and traveled openly in 

vulnerable locations but suffered no harm.  “If there wasn’t 

a constant and convincing priority from the top on 

non-violence, these people would have been attacked,” he 

concluded. 

¶7.  (C) Biti he believed Coltart’s stated convictions were 

genuine but naQve and played to his personal aggrandizement 

at the expense of the party.  Coltart was more concerned with 

international audiences more than local ones.  Biti said 

Coltart “saw everything in black and white — in a literal 

not a figurative sense.”  Race and place colored all his 

views.  Biti compared Coltart unfavorably with Roy Bennett, 

the nationally popular party treasurer who “speaks Shona 

better than me.”  Bennett was culturally Zimbabwean; Coltart, 

who spoke not a word of local language, would always be an 

outsider. “

• Zimbabwe 1 Liberia 0!! Katsande goal – thankfully although the cricket is disastrous the football is not #
• Zimbabwe Warriors 2 – Liberia 0 at half time!! Also nice to see Tatenda Taibu digging in and fighting back in Bulawayo. That's the spirit! #
• Things looking much better all round – Zim still 2/0 up against Liberia in the 37th minute of 2nd half – cricketers still alive in Bulawayo #
• Zimbabwe 3 Liberia 0. Taibu and Jarvis still battling away in Bulawayo – excellent end to the afternoon. #
• Taibu and Jarvis have taught all of us Zimbabweans to never give up – whatever the situation, whatever the game – magnificent performance #
• Now off to support Zimbabwe in their Africa Olympic hockey qualifying match against South Africa – a tough ask but I hope they do their best #
• Biased support of ZANU, judiciary and police for the minority Kunonga faction of the Anglican Church an appalling assault by state on church #
• Alan Butcher: 'We'll be a tougher prospect in the next World Cup' http://t.co/XHpRHKw via @espncricinfo #
• Life Under Challenging Regimes: Argentina and Zimbabwe: http://t.co/1ztBEmA via @AddThis #
• Another gold medal for Kirsty Coventry – congrats to our golden swimming girl – you make us SO PROUD!! #
• Good luck to all the Zimbabweans helping other nations in the RWC such as David Pocock – looking forward to when Zim itself is back in RWC #
• Note who was next to Australia's Ben Alexander forcing him across to score against Italy – none other than Zimbabwe's David Pocock #
• Not happy with DSTV – replaced Zimbabwe cricket with European golf – usual arrogance we have come to expect from south of the Limpopo #